When discussing the best careers in the history of the NHL, legendary names like Wayne Gretzky, Mario Lemieux, and Bobby Orr often dominate the conversation. But in the 21st century, two icons stand head and shoulders above the rest: Sidney Crosby and Alexander Ovechkin. Sharing a rookie year (2005-06) has linked them forever like Magic Johnson and Larry Bird, and both have piled up awards, records, and unforgettable moments. So, who ranks higher on the list of greatest hockey players of all time — Crosby or Ovechkin? Let's compare and contrast.
The Case for Sidney Crosby
Sidney Crosby's stats are a testament to his all-around brilliance. He's amassed over 600 goals and 1,000 assists, averaging more than a point per game in each of his 20 seasons. With 102 points as an 18 year old rookie, Sid the Kid announced himself as a generational talent, and he's been the face of the Pittsburgh Penguins ever since. In 2009 he became the youngest captain to lead his team to a championship, and he won the Conn Smythe Trophy as playoff MVP each of the other two times he hoisted the Stanley Cup (2016, 2017). His additional accolades include two Hart Trophies (MVP), two Art Ross Trophies (points leader), and two Maurice Richard Trophies (goals leader).
Crosby's greatness lies in his complete game. He's a wizard with the puck, combining elite vision, playmaking, and a relentless motor. His defensive prowess, faceoff dominance, and clutch performances — like his iconic golden goal for Team Canada in the final of the 2010 Olympics — set him apart. He's led the Penguins to sustained success, with his leadership as captain and ability to elevate teammates making him the quintessential two-way forward, often likened to legends like Steve Yzerman.
The Case for Alexander Ovechkin
Alex Ovechkin's goal tally is the highest in NHL history. Despite playing in a much lower-scoring era, he recently surpassed Wayne Gretzky's all time record for career goals (894), which had long been considered unbreakable. Ovi's 52-goal rookie season signaled the arrival of a scoring machine, and he's currently within striking distance of becoming the first player to score a thousand. His goals-per-game average is among the highest ever, and he's earned the Maurice Richard Trophy a record nine times. He was awarded the Conn Smythe in 2018 for captaining the Washington Capitals to their first ever championship, and has also won three Hart Trophies.
Ovechkin's case rests on his physical dominance and unparalleled ability to light the lamp. His one-timer from the left circle is the most feared shot in hockey, and even as he approaches 40 years old he's still a 40+ goal threat. His 2018 Cup run, during which he led all playoff scorers with 15 goals, silenced critics who questioned his postseason mettle. Ovi's consistency and durability make him a force of nature, comparable to Gordie Howe for his blend of skill and grit.
Why the Debate Isn't Clear Cut
Neither player has clearly outperformed the other, but many advanced statistics favor Crosby's all-around impact due to Ovechkin's inferior +/- along with his weaker defensive metrics and lower assist totals. However, Crosby has struggled with injury issues at various times, whereas Ovechkin has been an ironman, missing very few games thoughout his career (incredibly, he only had to sit out 16 contests after breaking his leg in his twentieth season).
Winning is crucial for GOAT status, and this is likely the largest differentiator between the two future Hall of Famers. Crosby's three Stanley Cups and two Olympic gold medals give him a decided edge. Ovechkin, by contrast, only has one NHL title, although his supporters would surely be quick to point out that hockey is a team sport.
The Leader in the Clubhouse
Many fans would rank Sidney Crosby higher on the GOAT list today. His two-way mastery and superior collection of rings, medals, and trophies place him in the top tier, arguably as high as the top five. Alex Ovechkin, with impressive hardware and the all time goal scoring record, is likely just behind, probably also in the top 10 and potentially the highest ranking player from Russia (or even Europe).
At the respective ages of 37 (Sid) and 39 (Ovi), both are still adding to their legacies. What's your take? Is Crosby's all-around brilliance or Ovechkin's goalscoring supremacy worthy of a higher GOAT ranking? Share your thoughts on our social media and vote at goat-vote.com/hockey/goat.